© 2022 WOSU Public Media
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations

Shuffle: Coby and The Prisoners Produce Large-Scale Songs Out of Small-Town Roots

Coby and The Prisoners from left to right: Billy Stansifer, Coby Hartzler, Matt Garver, Joey Weaver (not pictured: part-time guitarist Jared Riblet)
Coby and The Prisoners from left to right: Billy Stansifer, Coby Hartzler, Matt Garver, Joey Weaver (not pictured: part-time guitarist Jared Riblet)

Indie-rockers Coby and The Prisoners latest album is showing off the band’s talent at producing homegrown recordings that are polished and radio ready. WKSU contributor Brittany Nader talked withfrontman Coby Hartzler about the band’s sound and his roots in the Dover/New Philadelphia area.



Making music from the heartland 

Frontman Coby Hartzler grew up in a religious environment and lives just a handful of miles away from the heart of Amish country. His lyrics aim to question the values he was raised on and is presently surrounded by, particularly in the song “Everyone” — his latest release last year with The Prisoners. 

The full-length album was released a little more than two years after “Candy Queen,” which contained elements of Americana, pop and blues. Listeners will hear a slight diversion or growth in “Everyone” with songs reflecting on societal issues that are top of mind for many audiences.


“It was sort of a transition phase like in my personal life,” Hartzler said. “My wife and I, we were moving, (and) I was kind of in the process of quitting my job.”These life transitions set the songwriter on the path to create and record more music.Hartzler’s large, life-changing decisions and deep moments inspired the album. 


Running a recording studio

At the same time, the frontman was putting together his ownrecording studioin a 130-year-old Victorian house in Dover. 

Hartzler’s wife, Elisabeth Yoder, said the studio helps him pay the bills, perfect his craft and support their young son.Hartzler and his musical collaboratorsBilly Stansifer, Matt Garver, Joey Weaver and Jared Riblet record their own material in the studio, which is the birthplace of “Everyone.”  


Owning, operating and crafting new music in Dover — located about an hour from Cleveland but right around the corner from smaller villages like Sugarceek — allows Hartzler to explore his musical capabilities without being financially strapped.

“(What keeps us here) is a question that my wife and I ponder daily, it seems like,” Hartzler said. “One, just financially, it’s so much easier, like I’m able to have a recording space and a house and still live super cheap. There’s also something I kind of enjoy about the small-town life.”

Coby and The Prisoners held their album release show for “Everyone” atThe Auriclein Canton and played Akron’sHighland Square PorchRokr Festivala few months prior, so venturing outside of the Dover area is still very much part of the band’s agenda.

“Even though we’re in a small town, we’re kind of nicely situated where there are bigger cities within an hour or two drive. Lots of them,” Hartzler said. “So I’d like to try to break into those areas a bit more. And then, also, constantly recording.”

Undergoing an evolution of sound

Hartzler is currently working on a more toned-down, acoustic album that he intends to finish recording with The Prisoners this year.

This sonic progression is all the more evident when listening to the bandleader’s work with his first group,State Bird, an alternative-rock outfit that fused boundless thrash with more melodic, gospel tones. Ultimately, it was louder and more brash than his recent music.

“I think the one theme that has remained the same is the looseness that I still kind of approach things,” Hartzler said. “A lot of bands rehearse a song, like, until they’re playing the exact same way and the exact same note every time. And that just bores me, and I can’t do it.”

State Bird was his first serious project as a musician out of high school. 

“I was always drawn to songwriting and being in a band, so even before I knew how to sing or how to craft a song, I immediately found friends that had a drum set and a bass guitar, and we formed a band,” Hartzler said.

The band got on a small record label and was an active part of the Dover music scene in the mid-2000s, which was arguably centered around, and perhaps born out of, the Dover Ballroom.

“(State Bird) never really broke up,” Hartzler said. “People are just moving away, and that’s when this project sort of started.”

"Everyone" album cover.
"Everyone" album cover.

He explained that Coby and The Prisoners originally served more as his own creative outlet and recording project, with the addition of featured players brought on when they were available to play a show or two.

“In the last couple years, I’ve been trying to be more active with it,” Hartzler said. “I like to keep it exciting and almost allow for surprises.”

Getting signed and releasing records

Coby and The Prisoners is currently signed toThe Record Machine, a record label based in Kansas City, Mo.

“Candy Queen” and “Everyone” were released on the label, which runs theMiddle of the Map Fest. The festival has featured bands like Spoon, Iron & Wine, Social Distortion and of Montreal, while the label itself strives to introduce rising Midwest bands to larger, widespread audiences.

“Everyone” is a standout album rising from Ohio’s music scene, with tracks like “Street to the Door” serving as a love letter to past DIY venues — in this case, the aforementioned Dover Ballroom — and songs like “Dead Hair,” that are a timeless, locationless fusion of bootgaze, Americana, dream pop and wistful, poetic reflection of changing times.

“Everyone” is available to purchase inCDanddigitalformats.Coby and The Prisoners will perform March 21 atHappy Dogin Cleveland and April 4 atBroadway Brewhousein New Philadelphia. 

Copyright 2021 WKSU. To see more, visit WKSU.

Amanda Rabinowitz
Amanda Rabinowitz has been a reporter, host and producer at WKSU since 2007. Her days begin before the sun comes up as the local anchor for NPR’s Morning Edition, which airs on WKSU each weekday from 5 a.m. to 9 a.m. In addition to providing local news and weather, she interviews the Plain Dealer’s Terry Pluto for a weekly commentary about Northeast Ohio’s sports scene.
Brittany Nader joins Morning Edition host Amanda Rabinowitz on Thursdays to chat about Northeast Ohio’s vibrant music scene.